District Judge Jeffrey Johnson signed the temporary restraining order on November 12, the same day Liz Murrill filed in state court. Within twenty-four hours, the CFTC and DOJ were in federal court trying to void it.
That sequence is the whole story. Not the rhetoric — Murrill calling Selig the "obsequious standard bearer" for Kalshi, Selig calling Louisiana's action an attack dressed as enforcement — but the litigation architecture underneath it. Two courts, two theories of authority, one question that neither has yet definitively answered: when Congress gave the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over swaps and event contracts under the Commodity Exchange Act, did it mean exclusive enough to strip a state of its traditional police power over gambling?
The CFTC says yes, and it has filed this argument eleven times before Louisiana. The agency's complaint characterizes Kalshi as a CFTC-designated contract market offering CFTC-approved products, which makes Arkansas's and Louisiana's enforcement actions not aggressive regulation but trespass on a federal scheme. The legal theory is clean. The litigation record is not.
Kalshi moved simultaneously, filing for a preliminary injunction against Louisiana in US District Court for the Western District. The company's argument tracks the CFTC's: the CEA preempts state law, the state has no authority here, and the restraining order should not survive contact with a federal judge. The motion hearing in federal court is scheduled for November 17. The state court preliminary hearing follows on November 30.
What makes the double-court structure genuinely dangerous for the platforms is that Johnson's TRO is live right now. It bars the named operators — Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase entities, Crypto.com, Norvig, Underdog, Gemini, ForecastEX, ProphetX — from offering event contracts in Louisiana without state gambling licenses. For ten days, and potentially longer if Johnson extends it at the November 30 hearing, those operators either comply or risk contempt in state court while simultaneously arguing in federal court that the state court has no power over them. That is not a comfortable position.
I have read preemption arguments in contexts where the federal statutory text was considerably more explicit than the CEA's event contract provisions. The CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction claim is strong on the face of the statute. What it cannot fully answer is the Sixth Circuit's recent reading, which gave states more room than the CFTC's theory allows. Louisiana's counsel will cite that. The November 17 federal hearing will show whether the Western District of Louisiana reads the CEA the way the CFTC does, or the way the Sixth Circuit does.
The consensus read is that federal preemption holds because Congress spoke clearly enough. I think the timeline tells a different story. Twelve state suits, a Sixth Circuit loss, and a restraining order that survived its first twenty-four hours suggest that "clear" preemption is doing more work in CFTC press releases than in federal courtrooms. The platforms are winning some of these and losing others, which means the legal question is not settled — it is being litigated serially, state by state, with inconsistent results accumulating into a circuit split the Supreme Court has not yet been asked to resolve.
The Commodity Exchange Act grants the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over swaps and event contracts, which the agency argues preempts state gambling regulation entirely. The CFTC characterizes Kalshi as a CFTC-designated contract market offering CFTC-approved products, making state enforcement actions trespass on a federal scheme rather than legitimate regulation. The statutory text on event contract provisions is less explicit than in other regulatory domains, leaving room for judicial interpretation of how completely federal authority displaces state police power.
District Judge Jeffrey Johnson's temporary restraining order, signed November 12, bars named operators including Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase entities, Crypto.com, Norvig, Underdog, Gemini, ForecastEX, and ProphetX from offering event contracts in Louisiana without state gambling licenses. The order remained in effect through November 30 and potentially beyond, forcing platforms to either comply with state law or risk contempt while simultaneously arguing in federal court that Louisiana lacks authority over them.
Platforms face a dangerous double-bind: they must either comply with Louisiana's state court restraining order or risk contempt charges in state court while simultaneously arguing in federal court that the state court has no power over them. The November 17 federal hearing in US District Court for the Western District will determine whether preemption holds, but until then, operators cannot safely ignore Johnson's temporary restraining order without exposing themselves to state court liability.
The consensus read among legal analysts is that federal preemption will hold because Congress spoke clearly enough on CEA jurisdiction. However, the Sixth Circuit's recent reading gave states more room than the CFTC's theory allows, creating genuine uncertainty about how the Western District of Louisiana will interpret the statute and whether it follows the CFTC's view or the Sixth Circuit's approach.
Continue reading.
Senate Democrats' letter gives states a procedural weapon against CFTC
Kambi frames AI trading as network-scale advantage in new ebook
Kalshi user sues for $580,000 after $308,000 in sports bet losses
Kalshi seeks $65bn valuation as Trump Jr. exits advisory role
A few more worlds
worth exploring.
From the FreeMalta ecosystem.
The AI Journey
Explore AI beyond the headlines. Tools, ideas and a place to start.
Explore the journey 02 / THE GARAGEThe Garage
The companies behind the names. Explore their stories and the people building them.
Open the garage 03 / THE DUELThe Duel
Two contenders. A closer look. Put products side by side before choosing.
Choose your duel 04 / MALTAINSIDERMaltainsider
Discover the B2B side of Malta. A different lens on business and opportunity.
Meet Maltainsider