Maryland's appeals court blocks Kalshi injunction as state battles spread
A federal appeals court ruled that Maryland can enforce its sports betting laws against Kalshi, handing state regulators a significant procedural win at the same moment the company is absorbing criminal charges in Utah and a CFTC-imposed halt on its Trump mention markets. Three separate legal fronts, all moving against the same company in the same two-week window.
The Fourth Circuit's ruling on the Maryland injunction is the one that carries structural weight. Kalshi's core legal argument across every state confrontation is the same: the Commodity Exchange Act grants CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over designated derivatives contracts, and state gambling laws cannot reach federally regulated instruments. That preemption claim has not been finally rejected — it has been deferred. Courts declining to issue injunctions are not courts ruling on the merits. But deference has a compounding effect. Each denial gives state attorneys general more procedural confidence to press forward before the federal question is settled.
The Utah situation illustrates how that confidence accelerates. After Kalshi sued Utah officials on preemption grounds and lost its motion before U.S. District Judge Robert Shelby, the Tenth Circuit declined to block state enforcement. The CFTC then filed its own federal suit against Arkansas making the same preemption argument, which the newsroom has already reported. Utah's attorney general responded by filing criminal charges against Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara — 13 felony counts. The December 4 court date in Salt Lake City is now set.
The criminal charge escalation is the development that separates this cycle from prior rounds of state pushback. Injunctions are reversible. A criminal proceeding against individual executives is not a regulatory disagreement — it is a different kind of pressure entirely, one that runs on a different timeline and answers to a different standard of review. The preemption argument that works in federal civil litigation does not automatically transfer to a state criminal defense. Whether it transfers at all is an open question that no appellate court has had occasion to answer.
Meanwhile, the CFTC's Nov. 13 order halting Trump mention markets cuts in an unexpected direction. The agency that is simultaneously suing Arkansas to defend federal exclusivity over Kalshi's contracts has also told Kalshi that it failed to certify those same contracts adequately. Mansour's pushback — that markets predicting presidential speech serve a legitimate hedging function, that tariff announcements moved trillions in equity value — is not a frivolous argument. But the CFTC's position is that Kalshi did not demonstrate adequate manipulation controls, not that the contracts lacked economic purpose. Those are different standards, and Kalshi has until December 11 to respond to the certification proceeding.
The consensus read on these events treats the state enforcement wave as the primary threat and the CFTC's mention-market order as a secondary complication. I think that framing is inverted. The state cases, however numerous, are likely to resolve in federal court on the preemption question — the CFTC's own Arkansas lawsuit is designed to force exactly that resolution. But the certification proceeding is an internal federal process. If the CFTC ultimately finds that Kalshi falsely certified compliance, the exposure that follows is not a state gambling charge — it is a federal regulatory finding against the company's core operating authority.
DraftKings, FanDuel, and Fanatics have all restricted or withdrawn from Utah rather than contest the attorney general's position. Kalshi has not. That choice preserves the federal preemption argument by keeping the litigation live. It also means the criminal proceeding against its founders proceeds on the state's schedule, not Kalshi's.
The Commodity Exchange Act designates certain derivatives contracts as falling under exclusive CFTC jurisdiction, which Kalshi argues prevents state gambling laws from reaching federally regulated instruments. Kalshi has made this preemption claim across every state confrontation, asserting that federal derivatives regulation displaces state enforcement authority. Courts have not yet ruled on the merits of this argument, instead declining to issue injunctions that would block state action while the federal question remains unsettled.
Maryland's Fourth Circuit declined to issue an injunction blocking state enforcement, leaving Kalshi's preemption argument unresolved on its merits. The court's deference to state authority without a final ruling on federal exclusivity creates a procedural gap: each denial of Kalshi's injunction requests gives state attorneys general more confidence to press forward before the constitutional question is settled. This deferential pattern has a compounding effect across multiple jurisdictions.
Utah's December 4 criminal charges against Kalshi executives Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara—13 felony counts—represent an escalation beyond reversible injunctions into individual criminal liability with a different timeline and standard of review. The preemption argument that works in federal civil litigation does not automatically transfer to state criminal defense, creating an open question no appellate court has yet addressed. Criminal proceedings answer to different procedural rules than regulatory disagreements.
The CFTC's November 13 order halting Trump mention markets claims inadequate manipulation controls while simultaneously suing Arkansas to defend federal exclusivity over those same contracts. Kalshi must respond to the certification proceeding by December 11, with the CFTC asserting a certification failure rather than disputing economic purpose. Prediction markets platforms like Kalshi cannot price outcomes on these contracts until the certification and December 4 Utah criminal hearing timelines clarify which enforcement framework ultimately prevails.
Continue reading.
Fourth Circuit split leaves CFTC preemption without a majority view
CFTC nominee Anonick calls sports contract regulation legally complex
Senate Democrats' letter gives states a procedural weapon against CFTC
Kambi frames AI trading as network-scale advantage in new ebook
A few more worlds
worth exploring.
From the FreeMalta ecosystem.
The AI Journey
Explore AI beyond the headlines. Tools, ideas and a place to start.
Explore the journey 02 / THE GARAGEThe Garage
The companies behind the names. Explore their stories and the people building them.
Open the garage 03 / THE DUELThe Duel
Two contenders. A closer look. Put products side by side before choosing.
Choose your duel 04 / MALTAINSIDERMaltainsider
Discover the B2B side of Malta. A different lens on business and opportunity.
Meet Maltainsider