A former CFTC special counsel said something worth sitting with. Peter Sanchez Guarda, who spent years inside the agency before moving to private practice, told Gambling Insider that Kalshi's habit of removing state enforcement actions to federal court may be directly responsible for Utah's decision to bring criminal charges rather than civil ones. The logic is straightforward: if a company's litigation strategy is to drain state resources by relocating every fight to a more favorable forum, states will eventually choose a weapon that cannot be removed.
Utah filed fourteen criminal counts each against Kalshi and its founders. That is not a regulatory skirmish. That is a prosecution. The question of whether prediction market contracts constitute gambling under state law, which Kalshi has consistently argued is a federal question resolved in its favor by CFTC registration, now has a different procedural home — a state criminal court, where federal preemption arguments land differently and where the reputational cost of litigation is not the same.
Guarda's read is that this is adaptive enforcement. States watched Kalshi litigate its way out of Nevada, Washington, and Michigan civil proceedings with preemption arguments, and at least one state concluded that the civil pathway is a gift to the better-resourced party. Criminal prosecution changes the calculus entirely. Bail conditions, founder liability, and the asymmetry of criminal discovery are not problems that CFTC registration solves.
The timing matters because it sits against a specific backdrop. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig issued an order requiring designated contract markets to end geofencing within thirty days or justify why they cannot, citing the Commodity Exchange Act's impartial access requirements. The order creates a direct collision: Kalshi is simultaneously being told by its federal regulator to operate in all fifty states and being criminally prosecuted in one of them for doing exactly that. That is not a regulatory gray area. That is a live circuit between two incompatible legal commands.
The companies that hold state gaming licenses — Fanatics, FanDuel, DraftKings — are watching this carefully because they have more to lose from criminal exposure in state courts than Kalshi does. Kalshi has no sportsbook license to forfeit. DraftKings, which committed substantial capital to its predictions business going into 2027, has Ohio and Massachusetts licenses that state regulators have explicitly conditioned on staying out of sports-event contracts. If Utah's criminal model spreads to those states, the question is not whether DraftKings can survive the litigation — it is whether the litigation risk reprices the entire commitment.
Guarda's framing — that Kalshi's federal court strategy caused this — assigns causation I would treat carefully. States have independent reasons to escalate. But the structural observation holds: a company that consistently forces its adversaries to fight on unfamiliar terrain will eventually cause them to find terrain where the advantage inverts. Utah found it first. Whether the criminal charges survive a federal preemption challenge is a separate question from whether other states read Utah's filing and open their own penal codes.
The Commodity Exchange Act requires designated contract markets to provide impartial access to all market participants across all states. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig issued an order requiring designated contract markets to end geofencing within thirty days or justify why they cannot, citing these impartial access requirements. This creates a legal mandate for prediction market operators to serve all fifty states without geographic restrictions.
Utah filed fourteen criminal counts against Kalshi and its founders rather than pursuing civil enforcement because Kalshi's litigation strategy of removing state civil actions to federal court—successfully deployed in Nevada, Washington, and Michigan—made the civil pathway ineffective for state enforcement. Criminal prosecution in state court prevents removal to federal court and changes the procedural calculus, as bail conditions, founder liability, and criminal discovery asymmetries are not problems that CFTC registration resolves. Former CFTC special counsel Peter Sanchez Guarda identified this as adaptive enforcement by states.
DraftKings and FanDuel face criminal prosecution risk in states where they hold gaming licenses, unlike Kalshi which has no sportsbook license to forfeit. DraftKings committed substantial capital to its predictions business going into 2027, but Ohio and Massachusetts regulators have explicitly conditioned their licenses on staying out of sports-event contracts. Criminal exposure in state courts could reprice the entire commitment to prediction market expansion for companies with existing state gaming licenses.
Kalshi faces incompatible legal commands: CFTC Chairman Michael Selig's order requires it to operate in all fifty states without geofencing, while Utah criminally prosecutes it for doing exactly that. Prediction markets on whether Kalshi prevails in Utah state court, whether the CFTC order survives judicial review, or whether other states adopt Utah's criminal model would resolve based on outcomes in state and federal courts—with Kalshi's viability and market access pricing the probability of each legal pathway.
Continue reading.
Fourth Circuit split leaves CFTC preemption without a majority view
CFTC nominee Anonick calls sports contract regulation legally complex
Senate Democrats' letter gives states a procedural weapon against CFTC
Kambi frames AI trading as network-scale advantage in new ebook
A few more worlds
worth exploring.
From the FreeMalta ecosystem.
The AI Journey
Explore AI beyond the headlines. Tools, ideas and a place to start.
Explore the journey 02 / THE GARAGEThe Garage
The companies behind the names. Explore their stories and the people building them.
Open the garage 03 / THE DUELThe Duel
Two contenders. A closer look. Put products side by side before choosing.
Choose your duel 04 / MALTAINSIDERMaltainsider
Discover the B2B side of Malta. A different lens on business and opportunity.
Meet Maltainsider