The two-to-one vote out of Richmond was not a surprise to anyone who had been watching the Fourth Circuit's internal disagreement develop. What made it significant was the one — the dissent that refused to accept the majority's reading of where state authority ends and federal derivatives regulation begins. A split appellate panel on a preemption question is not a closed door. It is an open one.
The court's majority held that Maryland gaming regulators can pursue enforcement action against Kalshi over its sports-related event contracts. The logic followed a path that state courts have been building toward for months: that whatever Kalshi's contracts are under the Commodity Exchange Act, they are also something that Maryland has an interest in regulating, and those two things are not mutually exclusive. The dissent disagreed, and that disagreement is now on the record.
Here is where I think the consensus has this wrong. The prevailing read treats the Fourth Circuit's ruling as a loss for Kalshi in one jurisdiction and moves on. I think it is something more structural than that. A published dissent in a federal circuit on a preemption question creates the kind of circuit-level disagreement that eventually compels Supreme Court attention — not immediately, not on this case, but as the same question moves through other circuits and produces its own split decisions. The New York remand back to state court, taken alongside this ruling, means the question is now alive in at least two federal circuits under different procedural postures. That is not a coincidence. That is a map of where this fight is going.
I am adjusting for my own tendency to weight the downside scenario. Even doing that, I do not think the upside case for clean federal preemption has improved this week. The CFTC quorum problem has left the agency without the institutional authority to settle the underlying regulatory question by rule, which means every state enforcement action forces the issue into court rather than into an administrative record. Courts are being asked to resolve a question that a functioning regulator would have taken a first pass at. That is a different problem for Kalshi in Maryland than it would have been eighteen months ago.
What the Richmond dissent actually preserves is the legal coherence of the federal preemption argument. It does not win the argument. It keeps it alive in a circuit where, without the dissent, the question would look settled. For the prediction market industry broadly, a live circuit disagreement is better than a closed one, even when the immediate outcome is a loss. The path to a definitive federal answer runs through exactly this kind of unresolved split.
The Fourth Circuit held that Maryland gaming regulators can pursue enforcement action against Kalshi over its sports-related event contracts even though those contracts fall under the Commodity Exchange Act, finding that federal and state regulatory authority are not mutually exclusive. The court's logic follows a path that state courts have been building: whatever status Kalshi's contracts hold federally, Maryland retains a legitimate state interest in regulating them. This framework treats federal derivatives regulation and state gaming oversight as overlapping domains rather than competing jurisdictions.
The Fourth Circuit's two-to-one split produced a published dissent that refused to accept the majority's reading of where state authority ends and federal regulation begins. A published circuit-level disagreement on preemption questions creates the structural conditions for eventual Supreme Court attention as other circuits produce their own split decisions. The New York remand to state court, taken alongside the Richmond ruling, means the question is now alive in at least two federal circuits under different procedural postures, mapping the litigation's trajectory forward.
The CFTC's quorum problem has left the agency without institutional authority to settle the underlying regulatory question by rule, forcing every state enforcement action into court rather than into an administrative record. Courts are being asked to resolve questions that a functioning regulator would have addressed first through rulemaking. For Kalshi in Maryland, this represents a different enforcement environment than existed eighteen months ago, when regulatory clarity might have been available through agency process rather than litigation.
A live circuit disagreement on preemption represents better odds for the prediction market industry than a closed one, even when the immediate outcome is a state enforcement victory. The path to a definitive federal answer runs through exactly this kind of unresolved split between circuits, which eventually triggers Supreme Court review. Market participants tracking Kalshi and similar platforms can use circuit-split fragmentation as a leading indicator of when definitive federal preemption guidance will emerge.
Continue reading.
Kalshi warns New York case may force national shutdown
New York mayor enters prediction market debate with cultural warning
State attorneys general seize on CFTC quorum gap in legal fight
DraftKings chief says betting rivals are evenly matched
A few more worlds
worth exploring.
From the FreeMalta ecosystem.
The AI Journey
Explore AI beyond the headlines. Tools, ideas and a place to start.
Explore the journey 02 / THE GARAGEThe Garage
The companies behind the names. Explore their stories and the people building them.
Open the garage 03 / THE DUELThe Duel
Two contenders. A closer look. Put products side by side before choosing.
Choose your duel 04 / MALTAINSIDERMaltainsider
Discover the B2B side of Malta. A different lens on business and opportunity.
Meet Maltainsider