Judge Colleen McMahon's ruling was blunt in a way that federal preemption decisions rarely are. She did not simply deny Novig's injunction request — she questioned the legal coherence of the CFTC's own position, noting that the agency's Interim Final Rule had long treated casino-style gambling products as outside its jurisdiction, then failed to explain why sports-event contracts should be treated differently. That observation, sitting in a 35-page ruling, is now the problem Novig carries into the Second Circuit.
The appeal matters beyond Novig. McMahon's finding that sports-event contracts are essentially bets on sports — not financial derivatives protected by federal commodity law — runs directly against the CFTC's theory of exclusive jurisdiction. If the Second Circuit agrees with her, every platform offering sports contracts in New York loses its federal shield, and the preemption argument the CFTC has been pressing across a dozen state cases develops a crack at its foundation that state attorneys general will work immediately.
The CFTC's public position, repeated through each state lawsuit, is that event contracts are swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act and that federal oversight is exclusive. Chairman Selig has staked the agency's credibility on that claim. McMahon's ruling does not say the claim is wrong as a matter of statute — it says the agency has not explained why its own prior rules don't contradict it. That is a narrower objection, but it is the kind that appellate courts treat seriously, because it allows them to rule against the agency without reaching the constitutional question.
Massachusetts Gaming Commission chair Jordan Maynard made a related point in written testimony to a House subcommittee, though his concern ran in a different direction: even if the CFTC wins every jurisdictional argument, consumers contacting state regulators about prediction market disputes get nothing. The agency has claimed the sector; it has not staffed for it.
That gap — between claimed jurisdiction and operational capacity — is the detail that the lobbying effort cannot address. It is also the detail that legislators in a newly Democratic Congress will find easiest to explain to constituents.
The consensus read is that the CFTC's preemption argument is strong and that a Republican-appointed federal judiciary will give it room. Having checked my own contrarianism against that view, the structural problem remains: the CFTC has not resolved the internal contradiction McMahon identified, and the Second Circuit does not have to reach a verdict on preemption at all to send the agency back to do that work. A remand on rulemaking grounds would delay the federal shield without ending it — which may be precisely what several state attorneys general are hoping the court delivers.
The Commodity Exchange Act grants the CFTC exclusive federal jurisdiction over swaps, which the agency has defined to include sports-event contracts. Judge Colleen McMahon's ruling challenges this classification by noting that the CFTC's own Interim Final Rule previously treated casino-style gambling products as outside its jurisdiction, creating an internal contradiction about whether event contracts are financial derivatives or sports bets. The CFTC has not explained why the same product should be regulated differently under commodity law depending on context.
Judge McMahon's 35-page ruling observed that the CFTC's Interim Final Rule had long excluded casino-style gambling from its jurisdiction, then the agency claimed event contracts are swaps requiring federal oversight without explaining the distinction. McMahon characterized sports-event contracts as essentially bets on sports outcomes rather than financial derivatives protected by federal commodity law. The ruling does not say the CFTC's statutory interpretation is wrong, but that the agency failed to reconcile its current position with its own prior precedent.
If the Second Circuit affirms McMahon's decision, every platform offering sports contracts in New York loses the federal preemption shield the CFTC has been claiming across a dozen state cases. State attorneys general would immediately exploit the crack in the CFTC's preemption argument to assert their own regulatory authority. Massachusetts Gaming Commission chair Jordan Maynard has also highlighted that even if the CFTC wins jurisdictional arguments, consumers disputing prediction market transactions receive no recourse because the agency has claimed the sector without staffing operational capacity to regulate it.
Yes—the Second Circuit does not have to reach a verdict on preemption at all to send the CFTC back to resolve the internal contradiction McMahon identified between its Interim Final Rule and its current position on event contracts. A remand on rulemaking grounds would delay the federal shield without ending it permanently, which several state attorneys general may be hoping the court delivers. This approach allows the appellate court to rule against the agency's immediate preemption claim while leaving the constitutional question for future resolution.
Continue reading.
Flutter invests $200m in prediction markets despite legal challenges
Public health experts warn of conflicts in health prediction markets
Louisiana hearing set for November 17 as federal courts weigh state bans
Robinhood's prediction market exposure lands it in Louisiana court
A few more worlds
worth exploring.
From the FreeMalta ecosystem.
The AI Journey
Explore AI beyond the headlines. Tools, ideas and a place to start.
Explore the journey 02 / THE GARAGEThe Garage
The companies behind the names. Explore their stories and the people building them.
Open the garage 03 / THE DUELThe Duel
Two contenders. A closer look. Put products side by side before choosing.
Choose your duel 04 / MALTAINSIDERMaltainsider
Discover the B2B side of Malta. A different lens on business and opportunity.
Meet Maltainsider