gambity
After hours / Gambity

Journey to the End
of the Night.

A soundtrack for the hours between the headlines. Load the player to connect to Spotify, which may use cookies and process data under its privacy policy. Nothing plays automatically.

Open the playlist in Spotify
Gambity › Markets › CFTC chair orders prediction markets to defy s…
Markets ✦ AI Analysis

CFTC chair orders prediction markets to defy state court injunctions

When a sitting member of the Senate Judiciary Committee calls a federal agency chairman captured by industry and accuses him of encouraging contempt of court, the language is a legal signal as much as a political one.

Eleanor Ashworth Senior Markets Analyst AI PERSONA ·3 min read ·4 sources

Senator Adam Schiff did not use the word "rogue" lightly. When a sitting member of the Senate Judiciary Committee calls a federal agency chairman captured by industry and accuses him of encouraging contempt of court, the language is a legal signal as much as a political one.

CFTC Chairman Michael Selig's order — requiring designated contract markets to remove all domestic geographic restrictions within thirty days or explain why they cannot — lands on top of active injunctions in Nevada, Washington, Michigan, and California tribal lands. Kalshi is currently barred from operating on the lands of two California tribes by a federal district court order issued by Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley. Selig's directive does not mention Judge Corley's order. It does not need to. The collision is already built in.

The CFTC's argument is structural: derivatives markets cannot function on a patchwork basis, the Commodity Exchange Act requires impartial access, and geographic restrictions violate that requirement. As a legal theory, it is coherent. As a practical matter, it asks federally regulated exchanges to choose between a federal agency order and federal court orders — a position that is not a gray area, it is a trap.

The harder problem belongs to FanDuel, DraftKings, and Fanatics. Each has voluntarily geofenced sports event contracts in states where they also hold gaming licenses. That was a business decision, not a legal one, made to protect the core sportsbook operation from state regulatory retaliation. Ohio and Massachusetts have both signaled that offering sports contracts could cost a company its gaming license. Selig's order doesn't resolve that threat — it just adds a second one from the other direction. These companies now have a federal agency telling them their voluntary compliance with state positions may itself be a violation.

What the CFTC has actually done here is accelerate a question that was always going to reach the Supreme Court, but was moving there slowly. Seven states have filed suits or enforcement actions. The Third Circuit sided with Kalshi; the Sixth and Ninth did not. That split was already the Supreme Court's invitation to intervene. Selig's order removes the remaining ambiguity about federal intent and makes it impossible for any circuit court to treat this as a narrow statutory question. The CFTC has staked out the maximalist position in writing, under a chairman's signature, in a formal directive.

Whether that helps Kalshi in the near term is a different matter. An agency order does not dissolve an injunction. Kalshi still cannot operate on those California tribal lands while Judge Corley's order stands. If it does so in reliance on Selig's directive, it is in contempt of a federal court. If it doesn't, it is out of compliance with a federal agency. The CFTC can say markets must have impartial access. It cannot, with a press release, make that true in a courtroom where an injunction already exists.

Schiff called Selig's position the most egregious attempt yet to undermine state law, the tribes, and the courts. That framing will appear in the next brief filed against the CFTC. That is not incidental — it is the point.
About this AI persona

AI-GENERATED JOURNALIST PERSONAThis is a fictional AI identity, not a human journalist. The name, portrait and biographical background form part of the persona. Articles are generated by AI.

Senior Markets Analyst

Persona backgroundEleanor Ashworth spent fourteen years at one of the three largest strategy consultancies in the world before the financial crisis of 2008 proved her right about everything she had written in three internal memos that nobody wanted to read. She was not one of the people who was wrong.

Add Gambity as a preferred source Choose us in your Google source preferences
Share this analysis

The Commodity Exchange Act requires designated contract markets to provide impartial access to all domestic participants, which the CFTC interprets as prohibiting geographic restrictions. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig's order requires all designated contract markets to remove domestic geographic restrictions within thirty days or provide written explanation of why they cannot comply. The CFTC's structural argument holds that derivatives markets cannot function on a patchwork basis when federal law mandates impartial access across state lines.

Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley of the federal district court issued an order barring Kalshi from operating on California tribal lands, but Chairman Selig's directive does not reference it because the collision between the federal agency order and the federal court order is structurally built in regardless. The CFTC order applies to all designated contract markets without exception, forcing compliance with the agency directive while active injunctions in Nevada, Washington, Michigan, and California remain in force. The omission is intentional—the conflict itself serves the CFTC's maximalist legal position.

FanDuel, DraftKings, and Fanatics voluntarily geofenced sports event contracts in states where they hold gaming licenses to protect sportsbooks from state regulatory retaliation, but the CFTC order now threatens that compliance as a violation of federal law. Ohio and Massachusetts have both signaled that offering sports contracts could cost a company its gaming license, and Selig's directive adds a federal enforcement risk from the opposite direction. These companies now face simultaneous pressure from state gaming regulators demanding geographic restrictions and a federal agency order demanding their removal.

The CFTC order removes ambiguity about federal intent and forces the Supreme Court to address the conflict between state court injunctions and federal agency directives, rather than allowing circuit courts to treat this as a narrow statutory question. A circuit split already existed—the Third Circuit sided with Kalshi while the Sixth and Ninth Circuits did not—which was itself a Supreme Court invitation to intervene. By staking out the maximalist position in a formal written directive under the chairman's signature, the CFTC has made it impossible for appellate courts to avoid the fundamental constitutional question of federal versus state regulatory authority.

FROM THE SAME DESK

Continue reading.

BEYOND THIS STORY

A few more worlds
worth exploring.

From the FreeMalta ecosystem.

Journey to the End
of the Night.

A soundtrack for the hours between the headlines. Load the player to connect to Spotify, which may use cookies and process data under its privacy policy. Nothing plays automatically.

Open the playlist in Spotify