Gerald Perez will walk into Old Billingsgate on Tuesday to argue that prediction market contracts should not be banned for retail investors. His counterpart, Laura McCracken, will argue that they should. The audience votes at 16:45. That vote will not change any law. It will, however, produce a number — and in a room full of people who price things for a living, a number has a way of traveling.
The debate is structured around a question the FCA has not fully resolved. In March, the regulator said the financial prediction products it had reviewed fell within its existing binary options framework — a category banned for retail clients since 2019. CySEC's chairman offered the same read to Finance Magnates in May. Two regulators, same conclusion, same month. That is not ambiguity. That is a position.
What complicates it is what happened in September, when The Times reported that the FCA had held conversations with prediction market platforms about easing that ban. The regulator has said publicly that contracts on sports and politics route to the Gambling Commission instead. Financial event contracts sit in the binary options bucket. Whether that bucket has a lid that can be removed is apparently still a live question.
The commercial side has not waited for the answer. IG Group agreed to acquire Underdog for up to $1.3 billion. Plus500 has distributed Kalshi's contracts since February. Interactive Brokers consolidated Kalshi, CME Group, and its own ForecastEx contracts into a single interface and left sports out entirely — a structuring decision that reflects, precisely, where the regulatory seam runs. When a broker draws that line in product architecture, it is because someone read the rules carefully.
The consensus read is that the FCA will hold its current position and that event contracts will remain in the binary options category until a formal review produces something different. I think that is too static. What the Interactive Brokers integration demonstrates is that institutional demand has already forced a segmentation between financial event contracts and sports or political ones. The FCA's March statement covered what it had seen. It had not seen a fully institutionalized financial contract stack sitting inside a regulated brokerage interface. It has seen one now.
That does not mean the ban lifts. It means the conversation the FCA is reportedly having with platforms is not a courtesy — it is the regulator adjusting its view to match a market that moved faster than the guidance did. I have watched this sequence before: a framework written for one product catches a successor product in its net, the institutional build-out forces a re-read, and the guidance gets revised along a distinction that was always latent in the original rule. The distinction here — financial event contracts versus gaming and political ones — is already embedded in how the largest brokers are positioning their product lines.
McCracken's argument for the ban will almost certainly rest on the binary options precedent: same payout structure, same retail exposure, same manipulation risk. She is right that the structure rhymes. Where I think she is wrong is in treating structure as sufficient. The binary options ban was a response to fraud at the distribution layer. The fraud was not in the contract design — it was in who was selling them and how. That is a different enforcement problem, and the FCA knows it.
The FCA's March 2024 statement concluded that financial prediction products fall within its existing binary options framework, a category banned for retail clients since 2019. CySEC's chairman reached the same conclusion in May. The regulator distinguishes financial event contracts, which sit in the binary options bucket, from sports and political contracts, which route to the Gambling Commission instead.
Interactive Brokers' integration of Kalshi, CME Group, and ForecastEx contracts into a single interface while leaving sports out entirely reflects the regulatory seam between financial event contracts and sports or political ones. This structuring decision in product architecture signals where a regulated broker reads the FCA's existing rules to draw the line between permissible and prohibited retail products.
The institutional build-out of financial event contracts inside regulated brokerage interfaces may force the FCA to re-read its binary options framework along a distinction already embedded in its original rule. If a formal review follows, the regulator could revise guidance to separate financial event contracts from gaming and political ones, potentially lifting the retail ban for the financial category.
The Old Billingsgate debate on Tuesday will produce a vote on whether prediction market contracts should face a retail ban, and that number will circulate among people who price things for a living. IG Group's $1.3 billion acquisition of Underdog and Plus500's distribution of Kalshi contracts since February suggest the market is already pricing in potential regulatory movement before formal FCA guidance changes.
Continue reading.
Flutter invests $200 million to expand into regulated markets
Kalshi GPU futures test whether AI costs can be hedged
Plaee and Underdog offer operators CFTC-regulated market access
Louisiana hearing exposes gap between federal law and public opinion
A few more worlds
worth exploring.
From the FreeMalta ecosystem.
The AI Journey
Explore AI beyond the headlines. Tools, ideas and a place to start.
Explore the journey 02 / THE GARAGEThe Garage
The companies behind the names. Explore their stories and the people building them.
Open the garage 03 / THE DUELThe Duel
Two contenders. A closer look. Put products side by side before choosing.
Choose your duel 04 / MALTAINSIDERMaltainsider
Discover the B2B side of Malta. A different lens on business and opportunity.
Meet Maltainsider