Federal judge in Louisiana faces two colliding injunctions on November 17
District Judge Jeffrey Johnson issued a temporary restraining order banning prediction market operators from offering event contracts in Louisiana. Two days later, Kalshi filed for a federal preliminary injunction in the Western District of Louisiana to stop the state from enforcing that very order. The CFTC then sued Louisiana directly to block Johnson's ruling from taking effect. By November 17, the same set of contracts will be simultaneously enjoined by a state court and contested in federal court, with the agency that regulates them as a named plaintiff.
This is not a complicated legal situation that has become a simple one. It is a simple jurisdictional question that has acquired an unusual number of venues.
The question is whether the Commodity Exchange Act's exclusive jurisdiction clause preempts state gambling law. The CFTC's position is that it does, that event contracts traded on CFTC-designated contract markets are swaps under federal law, and that Louisiana has no authority to ban them any more than it could regulate the Chicago Mercantile Exchange's interest rate futures. Louisiana AG Liz Murrill's position is that what Kalshi sells to retail customers in her state is gambling by another name, that no federal rebranding changes what a wager is, and that judges across the country have been calling it gambling.
Murrill is not wrong that state courts have been skeptical. The Sixth Circuit's preemption ruling went against the federal argument, and that precedent now sits behind every state AG who wants to file. What the federal preemption argument has in its favor is the statutory text itself — the CEA's exclusivity language is unusually direct — and a CFTC chairman, Michael Selig, who has chosen to treat every state enforcement action as a jurisdictional incursion worth litigating.
Selig's posture deserves scrutiny. He has staked the agency's credibility on a preemption theory in multiple states simultaneously, at a moment when the Sixth Circuit has already found against him. That is not standard regulatory behavior. It is a bet that one federal appellate court will ultimately validate the CEA's exclusivity clause in a way that forecloses state action — and that this bet will pay off before the litigation costs and adverse rulings pile high enough to become a political problem for the agency.
Murrill, for her part, called Selig an "obsequious standard bearer" for the industry. The phrasing is worth noting because it locates the objection: she is arguing that the CFTC is acting on behalf of the platforms it regulates, not in the public interest. That framing will find a receptive audience in Congress, where the Massachusetts Gaming Chair has already told the relevant committee that the CFTC lacks adequate consumer protections.
The November 17 hearing is narrow. It concerns whether the state TRO should be extended or dissolved. But the briefs being filed this week will also sketch the competing theories of preemption that will travel up through the appellate system regardless of how Johnson rules. What happens in Tangipahoa Parish on November 17 is a data point. What the Fifth Circuit does with the same question is the event that matters.
The consensus read is that the federal preemption argument is strong enough to survive. After checking that read against the Sixth Circuit outcome and the breadth of state opposition, it holds — but only barely, and only if the Supreme Court eventually takes the question. At every court below that level, the outcome is genuinely open.
The Commodity Exchange Act grants the CFTC exclusive authority over event contracts traded on CFTC-designated contract markets, classifying them as swaps under federal law rather than gambling. Under this framework, the CFTC argues that states like Louisiana cannot ban these contracts any more than they could regulate the Chicago Mercantile Exchange's interest rate futures. The statutory text of the CEA contains unusually direct exclusivity language that forms the basis of the federal preemption argument against state enforcement actions.
The Sixth Circuit ruled against the federal preemption argument, finding that states retain authority to regulate prediction market contracts as gambling within their borders. This precedent now backs every state attorney general who wants to file enforcement actions, including Louisiana AG Liz Murrill's position that what prediction market operators sell to retail customers is wagering by another name regardless of federal rebranding. The ruling stands as direct precedent against the CFTC's jurisdictional theory.
By November 17, the same set of prediction market contracts will be simultaneously enjoined by Louisiana state court under District Judge Jeffrey Johnson's temporary restraining order and contested in federal court through Kalshi's preliminary injunction request and the CFTC's direct lawsuit against Louisiana. This creates a collision where the contracts are banned by state authority while the federal regulator that oversees them is actively litigating to invalidate that ban, leaving operators in legal limbo.
CFTC Chairman Michael Selig has chosen to litigate every state enforcement action as a jurisdictional incursion, staking the agency's credibility on preemption theory across multiple states simultaneously despite the adverse Sixth Circuit precedent. Louisiana AG Murrill has countered by framing the CFTC as acting on behalf of the platforms it regulates rather than in the public interest—a characterization gaining traction in Congress, where the Massachusetts Gaming Chair has already told the relevant committee that the CFTC lacks adequate consumer protections.
Continue reading.
Massachusetts regulator calls for stricter prediction market rules
DraftKings avoids court battle over prediction market legal issues
Sports and crypto drove prediction market record as politics lagged
Gambling Commission faces parliamentary inquiry call from Craig
A few more worlds
worth exploring.
From the FreeMalta ecosystem.
The AI Journey
Explore AI beyond the headlines. Tools, ideas and a place to start.
Explore the journey 02 / THE GARAGEThe Garage
The companies behind the names. Explore their stories and the people building them.
Open the garage 03 / THE DUELThe Duel
Two contenders. A closer look. Put products side by side before choosing.
Choose your duel 04 / MALTAINSIDERMaltainsider
Discover the B2B side of Malta. A different lens on business and opportunity.
Meet Maltainsider