Five days from now, at Old Billingsgate, an audience of finance professionals will vote on whether prediction markets should be banned for retail investors. The motion puts two people on opposite sides of a stage: Gerald Perez, Chief Executive of Interactive Brokers UK, arguing against; Laura McCracken of Blackheath Advisors, arguing for. The result is non-binding. It will be read anyway.
The London Summit debate matters because the FCA has not settled this question, and the room knows it. The regulator banned binary options for retail clients in 2019 and said earlier this year that the financial prediction products it had reviewed fall into that category. Sports and politics contracts were redirected to the Gambling Commission. That split jurisdiction is awkward and everyone involved understands it to be provisional.
What makes the timing pointed is the news in September that the FCA had held talks with prediction market platforms about easing the ban. No outcome has been reported. The conversation happening at all is the signal. Regulators do not hold exploratory talks with an industry they have already decided to eliminate.
The industry's posture in London reflects this. IG Group has agreed to buy Underdog for up to $1.3 billion. Plus500 has been distributing Kalshi contracts since February. Interactive Brokers brought Kalshi, CME Group, and its own ForecastEx contracts into a single interface. These are not the moves of firms treating the European regulatory environment as closed. They are bets on a different outcome.
CySEC's chairman told Finance Magnates in May that prediction markets would most likely fall within the binary options category under his reading of the rules. That framing — identical product, different marketing — is precisely what McCracken will be arguing from the pro-ban side. The question she needs the room to answer is whether calling something a contract rather than a bet changes what it does to a retail investor who guesses wrong.
Perez's counter-argument runs through the institutional session earlier the same day, where speakers from Kalshi, Webull Securities UK, Solidus Labs, and others will make the case that event contracts belong in a financial framework. The logic is that price discovery on binary outcomes has genuine economic value, that the binary options precedent involved fraud as much as structure, and that demand from retail participants does not disappear when a regulator draws a line — it migrates to less regulated venues.
I find the second point underweighted in most European coverage of this debate. The FCA's binary options ban was partly a response to boiler-room fraud in Cyprus-registered firms targeting UK retail clients. That history shaped the regulatory reflex. Prediction markets run by CFTC-registered entities with public order books are a structurally different problem, and conflating them because both resolve to yes or no is an analytical shortcut that the pro-ban side has not yet had to justify under serious pressure.
My read is that the FCA does not extend the binary options framework to cover all prediction market products. The September talks suggest the regulator is looking for a path that distinguishes financial event contracts from sports and politics, which is exactly the boundary Interactive Brokers drew when it built its interface. The vote at Old Billingsgate will not decide that. But if Perez wins the room by a wide margin, someone in the FCA will notice.
The FCA banned binary options for retail clients in 2019 and determined in 2023 that financial prediction products fall into that category, while redirecting sports and politics contracts to the Gambling Commission. This split jurisdiction between the FCA and Gambling Commission remains provisional and unsettled, leaving the regulatory framework for prediction markets unclear.
The FCA's exploratory talks with prediction market platforms signal that regulators have not decided to eliminate the industry entirely, contradicting an interpretation of the ban as final. Regulators do not conduct such conversations with sectors they have already determined to close, suggesting the agency is considering whether prediction markets deserve a different regulatory treatment than the binary options firms that engaged in boiler-room fraud.
Perez's argument holds that retail demand does not disappear when a regulator draws a line—it migrates to less regulated venues. This means a prohibition could push UK retail clients toward offshore platforms with weaker oversight rather than eliminate participation in prediction markets altogether.
IG Group agreed to buy Underdog for up to $1.3 billion, Plus500 began distributing Kalshi contracts in February, and Interactive Brokers unified contracts from Kalshi, CME Group, and ForecastEx into a single interface. These acquisitions and integrations suggest major firms are betting on regulatory permission rather than treating the European environment as permanently closed.
Continue reading.
Trader profits from Trump speech contracts with access to drafts
Federal Court Opens Second Challenge to Prediction Market Rules
Americans back stricter gambling rules for prediction markets
PrizePicks spent $636,000 lobbying for federal oversight it may not get
A few more worlds
worth exploring.
From the FreeMalta ecosystem.
The AI Journey
Explore AI beyond the headlines. Tools, ideas and a place to start.
Explore the journey 02 / THE GARAGEThe Garage
The companies behind the names. Explore their stories and the people building them.
Open the garage 03 / THE DUELThe Duel
Two contenders. A closer look. Put products side by side before choosing.
Choose your duel 04 / MALTAINSIDERMaltainsider
Discover the B2B side of Malta. A different lens on business and opportunity.
Meet Maltainsider