gambity
After hours / Gambity

Journey to the End
of the Night.

A soundtrack for the hours between the headlines. Load the player to connect to Spotify, which may use cookies and process data under its privacy policy. Nothing plays automatically.

Open the playlist in Spotify
Gambity › Trade Desk › Louisiana becomes twelfth state to face federa…
Trade Desk ✦ AI Analysis

Louisiana becomes twelfth state to face federal preemption suit

The day before, the CFTC and DOJ had sued her state in federal court, asking a judge to void the temporary restraining order she had won hours after filing her own lawsuit on November 12.

Sebastian Montague Prediction Markets Trader AI PERSONA ·3 min read

Liz Murrill called Michael Selig an "obsequious standard bearer" for Kalshi. That was Saturday. The day before, the CFTC and DOJ had sued her state in federal court, asking a judge to void the temporary restraining order she had won hours after filing her own lawsuit on November 12.

The sequence compressed what has been a slow jurisdictional argument into something that now moves by the day. Murrill filed in state court, named roughly thirty entities including Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, and Coinbase, and had a restraining order in hand the same afternoon. District Judge Jeffrey Johnson gave her ten days. The federal government gave her one before it responded.

Louisiana is the twelfth state the CFTC has sued over prediction market enforcement. That number matters less as a count than as a signal about where the CFTC chairman thinks this fight has to be won. Selig has consistently argued that event contracts are swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, that the CEA gives the commission exclusive jurisdiction, and that any state action against a CFTC-designated contract market is preempted by federal law. The Arkansas complaint made the same argument earlier this month. So did the ones before it.

The preemption theory is not frivolous. The Sixth Circuit has already ruled against it in one context, which is why the CFTC keeps filing rather than waiting for a single clean appellate ruling to settle the question. Each new state suit is partly legal defense and partly an attempt to generate a circuit split that eventually forces the Supreme Court to decide what the CEA actually covers.

Where I think the consensus gets this wrong is in reading the string of federal suits as a show of strength. Twelve complaints filed across a wide geographic and political range of states tells me the CFTC does not have a ruling it can cite to make states stop. If Selig had won a clean preemption holding that federal courts were prepared to follow uniformly, he would not need to file in Independence County, Arkansas and the Western District of Louisiana in the same week. The volume of litigation is evidence of a gap in settled law, not a demonstration that the gap is closed.

The November 17 motion hearing in the Louisiana federal case is the next fixed point. What the court does with the CFTC's request to void the state TRO will tell the market something the existing filings cannot: whether a federal judge in Louisiana is prepared to extend the same deference to CFTC jurisdiction that the agency is asking for. Johnson's state court order runs for ten days unless extended, with a preliminary hearing set for November 30. The two proceedings now run in parallel, each capable of producing a ruling that complicates the other.

Murrill's public attack on Selig personally is worth reading as a strategic choice rather than frustration. Framing the CFTC chairman as captured by industry is an argument she can make to appellate judges as well as to the press. It shifts the dispute from dry preemption doctrine toward a question about whether the regulator is actually regulating or simply running cover for the platforms it oversees. That is a harder claim to dismiss with a citation to the CEA.

The operators named in the Louisiana TRO are sitting in a gap the federal filings were meant to close but have not yet closed. The restraining order is live until November 17 at the earliest.
About this AI persona

AI-GENERATED JOURNALIST PERSONAThis is a fictional AI identity, not a human journalist. The name, portrait and biographical background form part of the persona. Articles are generated by AI.

Prediction Markets Trader

Persona backgroundSebastian Montague left a major Swiss investment bank's structured products desk in 2013 to trade prediction markets with his own capital at a time when almost nobody in finance took them seriously. He understood that the correct moment to enter a space is when serious people have decided it is too small or too regulated to matter.

Add Gambity as a preferred source Choose us in your Google source preferences
Share this analysis

The CFTC argues that event contracts qualify as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, granting the commission exclusive federal jurisdiction over CFTC-designated contract markets. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig has consistently maintained that the CEA vests this authority in the federal regulator, and that any state action against such markets is preempted by federal law. This interpretation forms the legal foundation for the agency's string of preemption suits against states attempting their own prediction market enforcement.

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill filed a state court lawsuit on November 12 naming roughly thirty entities including Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, and Coinbase, and won a temporary restraining order from District Judge Jeffrey Johnson the same afternoon. Johnson's order gives Murrill ten days to pursue the case, with a preliminary hearing scheduled for November 30. The article does not specify the substantive grounds for the restraining order beyond Murrill's enforcement action against the prediction market operators.

The CFTC and DOJ sued Louisiana in federal court on November 13 asking a judge to void Murrill's temporary restraining order, with a motion hearing scheduled for November 17. The two proceedings now run in parallel, and each is capable of producing a ruling that complicates the other. If the federal court accepts the CFTC's preemption argument before Johnson's state order expires, Louisiana's enforcement action could be invalidated before reaching a preliminary hearing.

The Sixth Circuit has already ruled against the CFTC's preemption theory in one context, preventing the agency from relying on a uniform appellate precedent to stop state enforcement nationwide. CFTC Chairman Michael Selig appears to be filing separate complaints across different jurisdictions to generate a circuit split, which would force the Supreme Court to decide whether the CEA covers prediction markets. The volume of litigation across Arkansas, Louisiana, and nine other states signals a gap in settled law rather than demonstrated strength in the CFTC's legal position.

FROM THE SAME DESK

Continue reading.

BEYOND THIS STORY

A few more worlds
worth exploring.

From the FreeMalta ecosystem.

Journey to the End
of the Night.

A soundtrack for the hours between the headlines. Load the player to connect to Spotify, which may use cookies and process data under its privacy policy. Nothing plays automatically.

Open the playlist in Spotify