Gerald Perez will walk onto a stage at Old Billingsgate on 24 November and argue that prediction markets should not be banned for retail investors. His counterpart, Laura McCracken, will argue that they should. The audience will vote.
That vote will be non-binding, procedurally meaningless, and probably the most consequential sixty seconds in the London debate all year.
Here is what makes it worth pricing. The FCA banned binary options for retail clients in 2019 and said as recently as March that financial prediction products it had reviewed fell into that category. Then, in September, The Times reported that the FCA had held talks with platforms about easing that ban. CySEC's chairman told Finance Magnates in May that event markets would most likely fall within the binary options category. The European and British regulatory consensus has been, until very recently, settled. The London Summit is the first public forum where it gets tested against a room of practitioners who have skin in the answer.
The industry argument is straightforward: IG Group bought Underdog for up to 1.3 billion dollars, Plus500 distributes Kalshi's contracts, Interactive Brokers built a unified interface across Kalshi, CME Group, and ForecastEx. The capital has already voted. A retail ban at this stage doesn't stop the product — it just determines who can access it and through which wrapper.
The counter-argument, which McCracken will make, is the one regulators have been making quietly for seven years. Binary options failed retail investors not because the label was wrong but because the payoff structure was. A contract that settles at zero or one, on a question the retail holder cannot hedge, in a market thin enough that the spread is punishing — that is the structure, whatever you call it. Rebranding it as a prediction market does not change the terminal distribution.
I think the binary options comparison is analytically correct and practically irrelevant. The comparison tells you about the risk profile of the contract. It tells you almost nothing about whether a ban works, because the demand is real and the product is now embedded in regulated exchange infrastructure on two continents. The FCA's 2019 ban on binary options worked partly because those products existed primarily in unregulated offshore venues. The enforcement problem was geographic. Prediction markets in 2026 are listed on CFTC-designated exchanges, distributed by Interactive Brokers, and backed by institutional capital. A retail ban in London does not make them go away — it creates a two-tier market where professional clients access the same contracts that retail clients cannot, and retail clients who want exposure find it somewhere worse.
That is not an argument that the FCA should do nothing. It is an argument that the binary options frame is the wrong map for this territory. The question the FCA actually faces is whether retail clients can be protected within a regulated structure, not whether the structure should exist. Those are different regulatory problems and they point toward different tools.
The audience vote at Old Billingsgate will not resolve that question. But it will tell you something about where sophisticated practitioners think the European consensus is heading, and whether the FCA's private conversations about easing the ban have shifted the room's priors. That is a signal worth reading.
The prediction markets that exist on this question are thin by any measure, and I think they are underpricing a partial accommodation — some form of regulated retail access with product restrictions — over a clean ban. The institutions have already moved. Regulators rarely ban what the institutions have already embedded.
Prediction markets settle on real-world events through CFTC-designated exchanges like Kalshi and CME Group, while binary options were primarily unregulated offshore products with zero-or-one payoff structures. The FCA's 2019 binary options ban targeted geographic enforcement against offshore venues, but prediction markets are now embedded in regulated exchange infrastructure on two continents with institutional capital backing, making a simple retail ban ineffective at preventing access.
The FCA stated in March 2024 that financial prediction products it reviewed fell into the binary options category, maintaining its retail ban stance. However, The Times reported in September 2024 that the FCA had held talks with prediction market platforms about easing that ban, marking the first public indication of potential regulatory flexibility after seven years of consistent opposition.
A retail ban in London creates a two-tier market where professional clients access the same contracts through regulated exchanges while retail clients cannot legally trade them domestically. Retail investors seeking prediction market exposure would then find it through offshore or less-regulated venues rather than disappearing, making enforcement harder and consumer protection weaker than under a regulated structure.
The debate between Gerald Perez and Laura McCracken will test regulatory consensus for the first time in a public forum with industry practitioners, occurring as major capital positions reveal market direction: IG Group bought Underdog for up to 1.3 billion dollars, Plus500 distributes Kalshi contracts, and Interactive Brokers built unified interfaces across multiple prediction exchanges, signaling institutional belief in regulatory acceptance.
Continue reading.
DOJ lawsuit against Arkansas sharpens federal preemption fight
Flutter invests $200 million as regulators crack down on prediction markets
Flutter's $200m prediction market bet lands as state bans multiply
Kalshi due process claim weakens as its own filings show preparation
A few more worlds
worth exploring.
From the FreeMalta ecosystem.
The AI Journey
Explore AI beyond the headlines. Tools, ideas and a place to start.
Explore the journey 02 / THE GARAGEThe Garage
The companies behind the names. Explore their stories and the people building them.
Open the garage 03 / THE DUELThe Duel
Two contenders. A closer look. Put products side by side before choosing.
Choose your duel 04 / MALTAINSIDERMaltainsider
Discover the B2B side of Malta. A different lens on business and opportunity.
Meet Maltainsider